Builders risk insurance (also known as course of construction insurance) covers buildings and other structures while they are under construction. There is a lot to know about builders risk insurance before purchasing a policy. If you aren’t already familiar with how these policies work, this guide will help you understand everything you need to know.
If you already have a good understanding of builders risk insurance and are simply looking for where to get the best policy, here are our top recommendations:
|The Hartford||State Farm||AIG|
|Best for||Best Overall||Custom Policies||Homeowners|
|Financial Strength||Strong||Excellent||Above Average|
|Learn More||View Rates||View Rates||View Rates|
Interested in Comparing Options With a Broker Instead?
The Hartford (Best Overall)
The Hartford is our top overall recommendation for a number of reasons. The company was founded in 1810, and they have earned strong financial strength ratings from AM Best, Moody’s, and S&P. Plus, they are rated highly with the Better Business Bureau. The Hartford offers a broad range of coverage options for builders risk policies at a fair price. They also sell other types of insurance for contractors, construction professionals, and homeowners. Read the full review of The Hartford’s builders risk insurance here.
State Farm (Best for Custom Policies)
State Farm’s builders risk insurance policy comes with several features like equipment breakdown coverage, ordinance and municipal law protection, and building coverage. Each of these can be customized with the help of a State Farm agent. In fact, State Farm is the most flexible option for builders risk coverage that we reviewed. Read more about State Farm builders risk insurance.
AIG (Best for Homeowners & Owner-Builders)
AIG earns our top recommendations for homeowners and for owner-builders because they are experts in the construction industry, but focus mainly on insurance policies for individuals and families. They are a reputable company with flexible and low cost builders risk coverage. Learn more about AIG.
Nationwide (Best for Contractors)
Nationwide is a high quality builders risk insurance option for construction contractors because they offer a full suite of other insurance policies specifically designed for construction contractors. This means contractors could go with Nationwide for all of their construction insurance needs. Nationwide checks all the important boxes: strong and flexible coverage options, fair to low pricing, exceptional financial strength, great customer service, and a wealth of construction industry experience. Read the full review of Nationwide’s builders risk insurance.
Chubb (Best for Commercial Developers)
We recommend Chubb for construction businesses because they have exceptional satisfaction ratings from large commercial customers. Additionally, they are a financially healthy and reliable company. Chubb works directly with customers to tailor their builders risk policies to the needs of the business and offers their policies at a fair price. Read more about Chubb’s builders risk insurance.
For everyone who does not know much about builders risk insurance, this guide will make you an expert. Here’s a summary of what this guide will cover. Click to jump ahead to relevant sections:
- The Hartford (Best Overall)
- State Farm (Best for Custom Policies)
- AIG (Best for Homeowners; Best for Owner-Builders)
- Nationwide (Best for Contractors)
- Chubb (Best for Commercial Developers)
- Zurich (Best for New Home Construction; Best for Renovations)
- Liberty Mutual (Best for Modular Homes)
Understanding Builders Risk Insurance Coverage
Before committing to an expensive policy with a new insurance company, it’s worth understanding how builders risk insurance policies work and how they might apply to your construction project or business. If you have not purchased a builders risk insurance policy before, the process can seem daunting, but this type of insurance is actually quite simple to grasp after just a bit of research. As a side note, if you want to learn more about other forms of construction insurance policies, visit our complete guide to all of the different types of construction insurance.
What is Builders Risk Insurance?
Builders risk policies always list specific types of property that they cover, which will usually include buildings and structures, fencing, temporary structures, foundations, piping, and more. Policies also specify particular causes of loss that the coverage protects against, typically including fire, extreme weather, vandalism, and theft. Most insurers also allow customers to add additional coverage for different types of property, causes of loss, and expenses by adding coverage extensions to the policy.
Builders risk policies are designed to cover only buildings and property under construction, so coverage usually begins when a construction project starts and terminates shortly after the project’s completion or once the building becomes operational.
Who Pays for Builders Risk Insurance?
Builders risk insurance covers the property while it is still under construction or remodel, but who actually buys the builders risk insurance policy? The answer usually depends on the details of the construction project’s contract.
Generally speaking, the project sponsor or property owner will want to ensure that their property is covered against potential damages during a construction project. However, the contractor or developer will likely also wish to ensure that their time, equipment, materials, etc. are covered as well.
This is where the contract details will come into play. Industry standard contracts, like those from the AIA, should include a clause about who is to buy the builders risk insurance policy and the policy requirements. Many local governments and large developers that contract out construction work for roads, schools, and other large projects will require that contractors carry builders risk insurance, along with several other insurance policies, like general liability, workers compensation, and commercial auto insurance.
In general, if the contractors or developers know they will be required to purchase a builders risk policy, they will factor that cost into their project bid, meaning that the cost of the insurance will fall back on the project owner, regardless of who the policyholder is.
Knowing this, project owners simply need to provide clarity on the subject of builders risk insurance within their owner-contractor contract. This provision of the contract should include (1) who is to buy the insurance policy, (2) the policy’s “name insured” (i.e. whose property is covered), and (3) any special terms requested by the owner or contractor regarding the builders risk policy.
Most insurers will work with buyers to customize the policy to the project’s needs. Sharing the terms of the contract with the insurance agent will help them define the necessary terms in the policy, including any additional covered parties, or “named insureds.” Having the details of coverage specified clearly in both the contract and in the insurance policy will simplify the claim-to-recovery process in the event of a covered incident.
In summary, purchasing the builders risk insurance policy could be either party’s responsibility, but the terms of the contract should be specific about who purchases the policy, what it covers, and who is named on the policy.
What Does Builders Risk Insurance Cover?
Builders risk insurance coverage can be most easily understood by looking at several components of the policy, which are (1) the covered property, (2) the covered causes of loss, and (3) the available policy extensions. Let’s take a look at each.
Builders risk insurance covers damage to a property while it is under construction. Builders risk insurance policies often can include coverage for the following types of property at the construction site:
- Buildings and structures
- Underground piping
- Electrical work and wiring
- Temporary structures
- Building materials
- Construction signs
Some other types of property may be covered under your builders risk insurance policy; however, you may have to add additional coverage with policy extensions (discussed below). Most standard policies will only cover the primary structure and items listed above by default.
Covered Causes of Loss
In addition to the types of property covered, builders risk policies will always specify covered “causes of loss,” identifying the specific events that qualify as coverable. Standard covered causes of loss include:
- Aircraft or vehicle collision
- Riot or civil commotion
- Sprinkler leakage
Similar to covered types of property, insurance companies will usually give you the option to extend your policy to cover additional causes of loss, which might include falling objects, weight of snow, ice, sleet, or water damage, to name a few. It will also usually be possible to extend your coverage to account for any cause of loss that isn’t explicitly excluded or limited in the extended policy terms, though that would cost much more than the standard policy.
Additional Coverage Extensions
Builders risk insurers usually offer additional coverage options to extend coverage of the primary policy. Usually when there is an event that triggers your coverage, there are some additional costs that fall outside of the standard coverage. Things like debris and pollutant cleanup, re-architect/engineering expenses, and labor expenses may be necessary and costly, so insurers will allow you to cover costs like these with additional coverage options.
Interestingly, many insurers structure their policy options very differently. While some insurers will offer a given policy feature in their standard builders risk policy, others might require the buyer to add that feature as a policy extension. And other insurers may only include that feature as part of a separate policy. Some insurers may not offer the coverage at all. Most of the additional coverage that we cover here will be offered by the majority of insurers in one form or another, usually as an extension to the base builders risk policy.
As we’ve pointed out, these additional coverage options may vary depending on the broker or insurer that the contractor or builder chooses. Not all insurers will offer the same coverage options. Furthermore, there are likely additional coverage options that we did not discuss here. Speak with potential insurance providers about the additional coverage extensions they offer to see whether any are applicable and worthwhile for your construction project.
What Is Not Covered by Builders Risk Insurance?
Because builders risk insurance policies are designed specifically to cover structures under construction and some related items, builders risk policies leave a significant amount of the construction project unprotected. It is important to understand the items and types of incidents that fall outside of the scope of the builders risk policy so owners, contractors, and builders can appropriately manage their risk with other insurance policies that fill their gaps in coverage.
This list includes what’s not typically covered by a builders risk insurance policy, but should be insured during most commercial and residential construction projects under a different type of policy.
In addition to those areas of the project that are not covered, builders risk insurance policies do not cover certain excluded events, which are always defined in the policy paperwork. Every policy will come with a list of exclusions, or events for which the insurer is not responsible for covering damages. Most often, policies will exclude the following items.
One note is that for almost all of these exclusions, insurance companies usually sell policy extensions or separate policies that add or extend relevant coverage. If you are concerned about any of the items listed above, it’s worth discussing your options with the insurance provider you are considering. Such policy extensions vary widely in cost.
Is Builders Risk Insurance Required?
Unlike certain types of insurance (for example, automobile or workers’ compensation), builders risk insurance is not compulsory. This means that there are no federal, state, or local laws requiring contractors, developers, or property owners to carry builders risk insurance during the course of construction. That said, maintaining a builders risk policy is oftentimes a contractual obligation depending on the nature of the project.
Typically, if the project is financed by a bank or other third-party financing company, their terms of financing will require the developer or contractor to purchase builders risk insurance.
Builders risk coverage is also required when a company seeks contract work from a local or state government or large organization. The terms of the contract will usually require contractors to carry several forms of insurance coverage, including builders risk insurance, commercial general liability, commercial auto, and workers’ compensation insurance policies. Contractors and businesses who bid for government-contracted jobs must purchase a builders risk insurance policy and all of the other required policies to earn and keep the job.
While builders risk insurance may be required in certain regions to win a government construction contract, they won’t usually be required for privately-owned residential construction projects. However, homeowners should consider the risks of not purchasing a policy before passing it off as an unnecessary expense.
When Should You Buy Builders Risk Insurance?
If you have decided to purchase a builders risk policy (whether it’s required by the project’s contract or not), it is extremely important to get covered before the project begins. This is because the insurance company will only cover the costs of work / property built after the coverage start date. Any work done before your insurance policy begins will not be covered.
If development has already begun when shopping for a policy, insurance providers will usually take note of the project’s progress before the coverage start date. Most of the time, they will even send a representative to the property to confirm what work has been done in person.
Related Insurance Policies
When first learning about builders risk, many buyers tend to believe it is unnecessary because their existing insurance policies will still protect them during construction projects. However, other insurance policies usually will not protect policyholder property or buildings that are damaged during the course of a construction project. Thus, it’s important to understand what your existing insurance policies do and do not cover.
Builders Risk vs. Homeowners Insurance
What is the difference between builders risk and homeowners insurance? Homeowners insurance is designed to protect homeowners from the cost of damages to their home and provide liability protection after an injury on their property.
While this sounds like it would encompass the same coverage that builders risk provides, homeowners insurance will not apply during a construction project on the covered home. In fact, damage while a property is under construction is listed as an exclusion on most homeowners insurance policies, as you can see in the “Section I – Exclusions” section (item B.3.c) in this sample homeowners insurance policy from the Insurance Information Institute. On the other hand, builders risk insurance policies only cover damages caused during the course of the construction project.
Builders Risk vs. Contractors All Risk Insurance
Contractors all risk insurance only applies to policies written outside of the United States, but it is merely a hybrid policy that combines the coverage of both builders risk and contractor general liability insurance policies. These all risk policies also usually offer various policy extension options. These non-traditional policies can be useful for contractors operating outside of the United States.
Builders Risk vs. Inland Marine Insurance
Inland marine insurance is intended to cover property at any location, whether it is in possession of its owner, in transit, or in the custody of another person. It is often used in construction by contractors to protect their tools and equipment, but it is common for many professionals who use and travel with expensive property or equipment, such as photographers and healthcare professionals.
Some insurers actually classify their builders risk policy as a form of inland marine insurance, even though the property being insured (the building) remains in one location. Most of the time, however, builders risk and inland marine policies are considered different forms of insurance with different purposes.
To complicate things further, some insurance companies will offer policy extensions to their builders risk insurance that cover the contractors’ tools and equipment. In this case, a separate inland marine policy is not necessary for the construction project, but this policy extension is not available with every insurance provider.
To summarize, builders risk insurance covers the building while it is under construction, and inland marine insurance covers the contractors’ equipment and tools (whether they are at the jobsite or in transit).
Builders Risk vs. Property Insurance
Commercial property insurance covers all types of commercial property (buildings, inventory, furniture, etc.) against covered causes of loss, such as fire, theft and natural disaster. However, when businesses renovate or build new buildings on their property, the additions are not covered by standard commercial property insurance policies while they are being built.
Builders risk is actually a form of property insurance, but it is sold separate from standard commercial property management insurance policies because its protections only apply to the property when it is under or construction or being built. Even if a business already has property insurance covering their building, they will need to purchase a separate builders risk policy to cover that same building during a renovation or construction project.
Builders Risk vs. General Liability
General liability insurance, in construction, protects policyholders (usually contractors or construction companies), from third-party liability. An example would be if a third party alleges that the contractor caused an accident or injury. Most contractors or construction businesses carry general liability insurance.
A contractor general liability policy may actually cover damages to an in-progress structure if those damages were caused by a subcontractor that the policyholder hired. But all other situations where damages could occur to the in-progress structure (fire, weather, theft, vandalism) would not be covered by the general liability policy.
Both of these policies will usually be necessary for any large contracted project in the United States. Those outside of the U.S. might consider a “builders all risk” or “contract works” insurance policy, which spans both areas of coverage.
Builders Risk vs. Installation Floater
Installation floaters are policy extensions for inland marine insurance policies that add coverage to equipment and property that is to be installed into a building or structure. Typically, the inland marine insurance policy will cover the contractor’s property, like tools, generators, and other equipment. Addition of an installation floater extends coverage to property that doesn’t belong to the contractor, but is to be installed during construction, for example, air conditioning units, water heaters, septic tanks, or roofing materials.
If a contractor is only installing something like an air conditioning unit or a hot water heater, builders risk insurance is much more coverage than necessary for the job. Adding an installation floater to an existing inland marine tool and equipment insurance policy will be the cheaper and more appropriate option to cover smaller projects like these.
Builders Risk vs. Vacant Dwelling Coverage
Vacant dwelling insurance policies are simple policies that protect against damage and theft to a home when it is vacant for an extended period of time, usually greater than 60 days. These policies are usually meant for homeowners who either cannot move into their new property yet, or landlords who own property that doesn’t currently have tenants. And while the home will certainly be vacant during a large construction project or remodel, the vacant dwelling policies will not cover the property during construction. Properties under construction will actually be excluded from coverage in the terms of the policies.
Builders Risk vs. OCIP
Builders risk insurance is actually a very common component of owner controlled insurance programs (OCIP insurance); however, they are two very different methods of insuring construction projects.
OCIPs combine workers compensation, builders risk, commercial general liability, excess liability, and other insurance policies into a single insurance program that is purchased by the owner and set up for contractors enroll in. Contractors who enroll gain the coverage of the entire policy.
Owner controlled insurance programs can provide nice cost savings to project sponsors through the bulk purchase of insurance for the entire project. An OCIP could be a great option for owners with large, or many similar, projects. Also, check out our section on OCIP vs. CCIP to learn more about how owner-controlled insurance programs differ from contractor-controlled insurance programs.
Builders Risk Insurance Cost
The exact costs of builders risk insurance policies are specific to the construction projects they are designed for, and several factors influence the final costs. We’ll explore those factors in the coming sections. First though, we’ll discuss the pricing and payment structure for builders risk insurance, which is similar to other forms of insurance.
Once the total price of coverage is determined for the full length of the policy term, it is usually divided into monthly payments that the policyholder makes for the duration of coverage. This is the main cost that the policyholder sees and it is known as the monthly premium. If no claims are made on the policy, then this is the only payment that policyholders need to make.
If a covered loss does occur, then the policyholder must also pay a deductible before their coverage begins to reimburse the cost of damages. The amount of the deductible is chosen by the policyholder when they select options for their coverage with the insurance company. Keep in mind, that if a covered loss does occur, this deductible must be paid for by the policyholder. While it is not an up front cost for the policyholder, it is still a possible cost that should be considered.
Generally, monthly premiums and the deductibles are the only costs that a policyholder should be responsible for. However, there are a couple of instances where additional costs may arise. First, if the policy’s coverage limit is not set high enough to cover the complete cost of damages in the event of a loss, any additional costs beyond the coverage limit will fall on the policyholder, unless otherwise set forth in the project contract.
Second, if you purchase through a broker or agent who isn’t directly associated with the insurance company that underwrites the policy, they usually charge additional broker fees, within the neighborhood of 10% of the cost of the policy or more. This can be a large cost relative to the value that the broker adds, which is why we generally recommend purchasing policies directly from a company that underwrites their own policies.
How Much Does Builders Risk Insurance Cost?
This estimate comes from a number of sources, including insurance agencies, expert blogs, and interviews with construction professionals. That cost is comprised roughly of the following:
- 1–3% for the standard policy (higher end of this range for projects with increased risks, complexity, or costs)
- 1–2% for coverage extensions
- 0–0.5% in broker fees (only if purchased through a broker)
Of course, these numbers are estimates, and broad ones at that. A project that the insurer deems complex and “highly risky” could require higher base premiums, while a simple, low-risk project would likely fall at the lower end of the estimated range.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
Factors that Determine the Cost of Builders Risk Insurance
Several factors influence the price of a builders risk policy. Unfortunately, there is no exact formula to determine the exact cost for your project. On a project-by-project basis, insurance company underwriters take in as much relevant information as they can and calculate appropriate policy premiums. Of course, each insurer has their own rules about how different factors affect the final policy price, but most underwriters consider the following information:
- Type of project – The insurer needs to know if the project is a new building construction or a renovation/remodel. Coverage for remodels and renovations can be more pricey than for new building construction because of the risk that the existing structure could be damaged. Replacing an existing structure would be much more expensive for the insurance company, so they require higher premiums to balance their risk. However, most insurers allow you to forgo coverage of the existing structure during a renovation, in order to reduce the cost of the policy.
- Type of building – The type of building—an apartment building, hotel, single-family residence, office building, etc.—will be a major determining factor with regard to policy price. Generally speaking, large, commercial projects are the most expensive to insure even on a percentage basis.
- Square footage – Applications will usually ask for the square footage of the project. Usually, more square footage equates to larger premiums, though other factors will influence the price of the policy more than this.
- Material / build quality – The types of materials used in the construction project could have an effect on policy cost for a couple of reasons. First, if the materials are exotic, unconventional, extremely high quality, or difficult to replace, they will cost more to insure. A separate consideration regarding the materials is whether they are prone to incident. For example, wood frames are highly flammable, and thus, more expensive to insure than other more fire resistant materials.
- Estimated cost of the project – Because the cost of a policy is roughly proportional to the cost of the project, it makes sense that more costly projects require more costly insurance. However, the project may become less expensive per square foot as the total cost of the project goes up. But that isn’t necessarily true for all projects.
- Location – The location of the project plays a big role in determining the cost of coverage. If the area frequently has intense weather, high risk of catastrophe, or high levels of crime, it may cost more to insure the build. Additionally, the proximity to fire stations and fire hydrants is considered.
In addition to the details of the project that the underwriter will consider, there are details about the policy that will also influence the monthly premium. Here are the major policy factors impacting price that the purchaser can control:
- Covered parties – The identity of the individuals and businesses covered by the policy is a factor that underwriters consider when determining price. Including subcontractors on the policy who have previously filed for bankruptcy or who have a poor track record of safety could increase the cost of the policy. Consider requiring subcontractors to carry their own insurance policies to minimize this possibility.
- Policy extensions – As we discussed above, buyers can extend coverage of their policy by purchasing any number of the policy extensions offered by the insurer. These extensions can add coverage for additional causes of loss or additional types of property, but they also add to the monthly premiums.
- Coverage limits – Coverage limits are how the insurance companies will cap the amount they have to pay out after a covered loss. By increasing the cost of the policy, policyholders can increase the limit that the insurer will pay out for a covered loss.
- Deductible – The deductible is the amount that the insured party must pay toward damages caused by a covered loss before the insurance company is responsible for payment. If the policyholder agrees to pay a higher deductible, the premium will be lowered. A lower deductible means a higher premium.
- Duration of coverage – Typically coverage is available in 6 or 12 month time periods. It is possible to extend the length of coverage, but doing so will also likely increase the cost of the policy. The longer the insurer provides coverage to a project, the more likely a loss becomes.
Determining Your Builders Risk Needs
Once you understand the coverage that a builders risk insurance policy provides and the costs associated with it, you may still be wondering if you should purchase a policy or not. On one hand, having expenses covered in case of a disaster seems like a great benefit. On the other hand, the policy adds a significant amount to the total project cost. Next, we’ll weigh each side of this common choice.
For homeowners and contractors in situations where a builders risk policy is not required, the question remains: is builders risk insurance necessary? The answer depends on the details of the construction project, your risk tolerance, and your willingness to spend the money on a policy.
Builders Risk Insurance For Homeowners
For homeowners considering a builders risk insurance policy for a renovation or new construction, weigh the following questions:
- How much is this renovation/project going to cost?
- If this project were severely damaged in a fire or other accident, how much would it cost to clean up and redo the project?
- What are the risks associated with this project?
- Is this project located in a high-risk area (extreme weather, high fire risk, regular crime, etc.)?
If you are a homeowner hiring a contractor to build a small shed or install replacement windows, the cost of the project and the risks associated with it are relatively low. But if you are doubling the size of your home through major renovations, risks are much higher. You may also have a homeowners insurance policy that excludes damages to your property caused during construction or renovation. In this case, builders risk insurance is the only way to cover your home throughout the renovation. Considering the potential downside, which includes losing your home, a builders risk insurance policy is likely worth the money.
In general, we recommend builders risk insurance whenever a structure is being built. For homeowners, the cost is worth the reduced risk. AIG offers flexible builders risk policies for homeowners.
Builders Risk for Contractors & Professionals
For builders, contractors, and construction companies, the cost of insurance is almost always passed on to the client for any construction contract, and it could be costly to go without it.
Finding the Best Builders Risk Insurance Policy
There are many builders risk insurance policies available to builders through different brokers and insurance companies. Where you choose to buy a policy will be the biggest determining factor in the coverage you receive, the amount you pay, and your experience as a customer.
Buying Through a Broker vs Buying Directly
Many companies advertising insurance policies online are not actually the companies who underwrite the policies and provide their financial backing. Most of these businesses are actually insurance “brokers” who connect you, the consumer, to the right insurance policy based on your needs. These brokers have relationships with one or more actual insurance companies who underwrite policies, which gives them some flexibility in matching your project to various policy options.
Brokers save businesses and consumers time and energy. With knowledge of builders risk insurance policies and the industry, plus experience providing policies for other construction projects like yours, these brokers can quickly identify your needs and find a policy that checks all the boxes. When you search for a policy on your own, it can be difficult to tell if you have all of the information and fully understand the coverage you need. Going through a broker can give this peace of mind to buyers.
Brokers can save you money, but that is only by connecting you to lower priced policies than you may have bought if you searched for a policy on your own. The reality, however, is that brokers charge fees when you buy insurance policies through them. Fees are generally in the neighborhood of 10% or more of the total policy cost. So for a broker to be valuable, they should be providing their customers with competitively priced policies, great fitting coverage, and excellent customer service.
For most buyers, we recommend purchasing a policy directly through a company that underwrites their own policies, and there are many to choose from. One downside of going directly to an underwriting insurer is that you’re limited to the range of coverage options that they can provide. However, if you are willing to do some research on your own, guides like this one can help you quickly narrow down the top options for your project and help you spot builders risk insurance providers that fit your project’s needs. The top builders risk insurance providers also have agents and representatives who can be very helpful in crafting the right policy for your project from the options their company provides.
What Differentiates Builders Risk Insurance Companies?
Throughout the course of our research, we analyzed dozens of underwriters and identified 12 that we are confident recommending. Below, we cover the most important things we looked at (and suggest you look at, too) when comparing various course of construction insurance providers.
Specialties & Expertise
Specializing in the construction industry is one way that builders risk brokers differentiate themselves from the larger insurance providers. They provide insurance only for the purpose of construction, so they know the industry well. However many of the larger insurers also offer expertise in construction.
Some providers will differentiate themselves by offering tailored policies to contractors or specific trades, which can save time and energy when crafting a policy to your needs. They also often have very knowledgeable staff with an abundance of experience in the construction industry or for particular types of builds.
The more effort that an insurance provider puts toward catering their policies to the construction industry, the more likely it is that they can provide the coverage, service, and understanding that you should expect from your builders risk insurer.
All of our top recommendations have knowledgeable representatives with experience working with construction professionals, and most have policies and policy suites specifically designed for contractors, construction businesses, and construction projects.
Financial strength of the underwriting company is worth consideration when choosing a provider. It’s unlikely that your insurance provider will be unable to pay the value owed to you in the event of a covered loss, but going with a financially stable company should eliminate that concern almost entirely.
Many of the companies we discuss below are public companies, whose financial information is publicly available for anyone interested in viewing it. If financial strength of the insurer is a sticking point for you, then it’s possible to view a company’s financial documents and determine for yourself how stable and trustworthy that company is.
Luckily for everyone, third-party companies review insurer debts and financial details to establish “financial strength ratings” and “stability outlooks” for each insurance company. There are many companies like this, known as financial rating agencies, but there are a handful that are considered most established and trustworthy. These financial rating agencies are:
- A.M. Best – Founded in 1899, A.M. Best is a Nationally Recognized Statistical Rating Organization (NRSRO) in the United States. They focus solely on rating companies in the insurance industry.
- Moody’s Investor Service – Moody’s was founded in 1909 and is a bond credit rating business. They are also considered a NRSRO in the United States. Moody’s Investor Service is a branch of the larger Moody’s Corporation.
- Standard & Poor’s – Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC (S&P) is a financial services company, and another NRSRO, who provides issuer credit ratings across the financial services industry.
These companies can give some great insight into a company’s financial situation, meaning you don’t need to dive into the details. Each of the financial rating agencies assigns simple ratings that give a gauge of the companies’ financial outlooks.
All of the companies that we included in our top list are at least “very strong” according to these major rating agencies. And the majority of these companies have over 50 years of experience as insurers.
Company Reputation & Customer Service
The insurance provider’s reputation among its customers is one of the most important considerations you should weigh. Anytime you need to change your policy, adopt a new policy, or file a claim, you will have to work closely with representatives from this company. Ideally, the representatives of the company are friendly, knowledgeable, experienced, and competent. This is not always the case.
J.D. Power is a global marketing information services company that performs consumer studies to evaluate the competitive landscape of different industries. Insurance is one of the industries that they evaluate, and the metrics they evaluate while surveying consumers include overall satisfaction, billing & payment, interaction, and claims. By looking at how existing customers rate companies on these metrics, new buyers can get a great sense of each insurer’s reputation and customer service.
A separate source of similar information is the Better Business Bureau. Customers who are dissatisfied with the service of any company can file complaints with the BBB. How each company handles these complaints determines their rating. High ratings with the Better Business Bureau mean that the company received few complaints and / or handled the complaints that they did receive appropriately.
Referencing these sources of information can give you a good idea of what it will be like to work with a given insurer in the future.
We only include companies in our top list that received high marks in customer service from at least one of these organizations—the BBB or J.D. Power—because good customer service is critical to a good experience with insurers.
The coverage options that the insurer offers are another very important, if not the most important, factor to consider when you’re purchasing builders risk insurance for your business or project. What good are their reputation and financial strength if they do not offer the coverage you need? Several strategies exist to evaluate the coverage options of a provider without going through the hassle of getting a detailed quote.
First, evaluate the depth of the company’s builders risk policy by reviewing the information that they provide on their website. It may take some digging to find the builders risk insurance content. If a company offers great optional policy extensions or has a very extensive base policy, they tend to advertise those things. If the policy is bland and not much more than the industry standard, they might not have that much to say about their builders risk policy. Use the information they provide to assess their policy because it likely shows how much they value customers of their builders risk policies.
Another great way to find out what the builders risk policy looks like for a given provider is to track down a sample policy. This will usually show the base policy and its exclusions in very clear terms, and also shed insight into the policy extensions available. These samples aren’t always available, but some companies offer them for download on their websites. Here are a few standard sample policies that will give you a good idea of what to expect within a builders risk policy:
- North Star Mutual – Sample Builders Risk Coverage Form
- Equestrian Group – Sample Builders Risk Coverage Form (Underwritten by Zurich)
- Cal Mutual – Sample Builders Risk Coverage Form
J.D. Power also evaluates “policy offering” as a metric for insurers in their insurer studies. Looking at where a company ranks among its peers in this category shows generally how strong a company is with the flexibility and depth of their policy offerings. And while the J.D. Power ratings we refer to are rating their entire commercial property branch, insurers tend to be on the more or less flexible end of the spectrum, even though the specific policies for each type of insurance will be different.
Lastly, you can call a company representative to get the details about their policies. What they cover, don’t cover, exclude, etc. These representatives should be able to easily inform you about which coverage extensions are available to you as well. However, be ready to share your contact information and details about the project. Insurance companies rarely like to share information about their policies before they validate your potential as a customer. Ideally, you’ll narrow your options before you start making calls and wasting time in conversation with insurance providers that don’t fit your needs.
All of the companies we list in this guide have what’s considered standard or above average policy offerings for the industry.
Pricing can be difficult to evaluate when comparing builders risk insurance providers. Most of the time, insurers won’t (or simply can’t) provide enough insight into pricing until you’ve gotten a quote, and in many cases, getting a quote can be a time-consuming process that requires a great deal of information and documentation from the applicant. Furthermore, very few builders risk providers offer instant online quotes, and for commercial customers, none provide online quotes.
One of the few insights into pricing you can find without comparing quotes is the data that J.D. Power provides from their insurance industry studies. One of the metrics that they survey insurance customers on is their satisfaction with pricing of their policies. We use this information to assess pricing for the companies we recommend. However, not all companies we recommend are on the favorable end of this spectrum, because sometimes higher quality policies are more expensive.
Best Builders Risk Insurance Companies
Finally, our complete list of the best builders risk insurance providers of 2019. In order to determine the top list of builders risk insurance companies, we searched the web for all of the top builders risk insurance providers.
Once we built the list of companies, we rated each company on several factors, which were: (1) construction expertise, (2) financial strength of the underwriting company, (3) company reputation, customer service, and claims support, (4) coverage options, and, lastly, (5) pricing. Here’s how the top companies stacked up:
The Hartford Builders Risk (Best Overall)
The Hartford is our top recommendation for builders risk insurance. They scored highly in each of the five categories that we evaluated and provide policies that can serve a broad range of customers and construction projects.
The Hartford is a public Fortune 500 company that serves over one million small businesses. Founded in 1810, it is also one of the oldest companies in the US. The Hartford is one of the most financially stable companies offering builders risk insurance. A.M. Best, Moody’s, and S&P all rated The Hartford with top marks with A+, A1, and A+ ratings respectively.
The Hartford does not specialize exclusively in construction-related insurance products. However, it’s team is very experienced in dealing insurance policies for construction projects and working with contractors and construction businesses. They offer a large number of policy options for their builders risk insurance coverage, and they also offer many other construction-related insurance options, including liability insurance for contractors and construction, workers’ compensation, and commercial auto insurance.
The company also has a great reputation with its customers, receiving an A- with the Better Business Bureau, even though they are not accredited with the BBB. J.D. Power also ranked The Hartford’s claims process and overall customer satisfaction as “Better Than Most” in their Large Commercial Insurance Insurer Satisfaction Study. High ratings with the BBB and J.D. Power usually translate to quality customer service and a smooth claims process for customers.
Their pricing is fair, though they are not the lowest priced provider of builders risk insurance. In their Insurer Satisfaction Study, J.D. Power also compared policy pricing of vendors and found that The Hartford’s policies were among “The Rest” of insurance providers, meaning they were more expensive than the average in the study. One perk they offer is the ability to pay only a single deductible if multiple deductibles are triggered on the same loss. And for buyers who prefer to support environmentally sustainable companies, The Hartford even won a Climate Leadership Award in 2018 for Excellence in Greenhouse Gas Management.
State Farm Builders Risk (Best for Custom Policies)
State Farm is a very large insurance company that provides many types of insurance to many types of customers. We rated State Farm as one of our top builders risk insurance options for a number of reasons, including their financial stability, coverage options, and strong reputation with their customers.
State Farm is a financially strong insurance business that was founded in 1922. State Farm actually received the highest financial strength ratings of any builders risk insurance provider we reviewed. A.M. Best gives State Farm a financial strength rating of A++, while S&P rates them AA, both indicating that State Farm is among the strongest insurance companies financially.
State Farm has a fairly strong reputation with its customers, receiving an A- from the Better Business Bureau. This indicates that they’ve done a good job resolving issues with their customers and provide satisfactory service.
State Farm also has a strong policy offering with a large amount of flexibility in coverage options. Their policies come with several features like equipment breakdown coverage, ordinance and municipal law protection, and building coverage. Each of these can be customized with the help of a State Farm agent. This is reflected in J.D. Power’s Small Business Insurer Study, where they rated State Farm as “Better Than Most” for their policy offering. Unfortunately, State Farm doesn’t offer much transparency on pricing until you receive a quote with them, but their policy pricing ranks about average in J.D. Power’s Small Business Insurance Provider Study, indicating that they are about middle of the pack.
State Farm is the most flexible option for builders risk coverage that we reviewed, which is why they are ranked Best Builders Risk Insurance Provider for Policy Customization.
AIG Builders Risk (Best for Homeowners; Best for Owner-Builders)
AIG is a very reputable provider of builders risk insurance and our top recommendation for homeowners and owner / builders. The biggest reason we recommend AIG for homeowners is that their agents will work directly with you to tailor their available policies to the specifics of your project. AIG’s agents will actually work this same way with businesses for projects of any size, which also makes them a great builders risk insurance option for medium-sized and commercial projects as well.
AIG offers a number of builders risk policy options, which makes their policies flexible, capable of working with a number of different construction projects. For large developers, they offer policy limits upward of $1.75 billion, so any homeowner will have no trouble getting a high policy limit for their project if they need it.
AIG’s financial strength is also quite good. The company was founded in 1919, so the company has been through many economic ups and downs, and is still standing strong. Furthermore, they receive top-notch financial strength and credit ratings from the major financial rating agencies, including an A from A.M. Best, an A2 from Moody’s, an A+ from S&P, and an A from Fitch. Few companies have a stronger collection of financial strength and credit ratings than AIG, so there should be little concern about their financial stability and ability to pay out any rightful claim.
AIG received an A- rating from the Better Business Bureau, meaning they’ve done a great job taking care of their customers and handling their concerns. AIG also works closely with homeowners, contractors, or business owners to tailor their insurance options to the project at hand. AIG has a clean claims reporting interface on their website, but also provides contact information for claims representatives if speaking to a human is necessary for the situation.
As with most insurance providers, exact pricing of AIG’s policies are not clear until you receive a quote from them. However, J.D. Power’s Small Commercial Insurance Study recognized AIG as “Among The Best” when it comes to pricing. Customers who participated in J.D. Powers survey are very satisfied with the pricing of their builders risk insurance policies.
All that said, AIG is a top insurance provider in many areas including builders risk insurance. They are a good fit for any size project and almost any type of customer. However, we believe that AIG is a particularly great fit for homeowners, which is why we’ve named them the Best Builders Risk Insurance Company for Homeowners and Best Builders Risk Insurance Company for Owner / Builders.
Nationwide Builders Risk (Best for Contractors)
We recommend Nationwide Insurance as the top provider of builders risk coverage for contractors, not only because of their builders risk offering, but because they also have a large offering of policies for all contractor insurance needs. For contractors, the ability to keep all insurance policies with one provider saves significant time, energy, and money. Nationwide’s full suite of quality insurance policies for contractors includes general liability, inland marine (mobile equipment & tools), business auto, workers’ compensation, errors & omissions, and more. Their specialized contractors insurance policies make them one of the more experienced insurers in the small business and contractor construction space.
J.D. Power awarded Nationwide as the top insurer in the 2018 U.S. Small Commercial Insurance Provider Study. That study rates Nationwide’s variety of available policy options as “Among The Best” which is the highest possible rating. Contractors can be confident that Nationwide will support their specific needs with their builders risk policy options.
Nationwide has an A+ rating with Better Business Bureau. Additionally, the J.D. Power study mentioned above rated Nationwide “Among The Best” in Claims, Billing and Payment, and Overall Satisfaction. So Nationwide’s reputation is not in question and buyers can be confident that the company representatives will be both friendly and knowledgeable.
The J.D. Power study also rated Nationwide among the best in terms of pricing. As is the case with most insurers, the exact pricing of the policy you’ll need won’t be clear until you receive a quote, but high ratings from J.D. Power mean that current policyholders are satisfied with the price and value of their coverage.
Nationwide was founded in 1926, so it is a very experienced insurance provider. Nationwide also receives high credit and financial strength ratings from A.M. Best, Moody’s, and S&P with ratings of A+, A1, and A+ respectively. In 2017, Nationwide generated over $46B in US revenue. They are a strong company with a solid financial track record.
Nationwide is our choice for the Best Builders Risk Insurance Company for Contractors, but Nationwide is also a great option for small construction businesses and even homeowners.
Chubb Builders Risk (Best for Commercial Developers)
Chubb is a large, publicly traded (NYSE:CB) insurance company that provides all types of insurance for individuals, families, and businesses. While construction-related insurance policies and builders risk are just a subset of all the insurance products they provide, they offer an exceptional suite of insurance products for construction professionals.
Chubb’s builders risk insurance policies are intended for developers, general contractors, and homeowners with ongoing construction projects. Chubb, for a large insurance company, does a phenomenal job of offering very specialized and customizable builders risk and other construction insurance policies. Chubb is more flexible than most insurance providers because they are able to provide tailored underwriting to their policies to fit a number of different situations. This is why we recommend them most highly for larger construction companies, particularly those who may work under special or unique circumstances.
Chubb stands out in terms of financial strength. A.M. Best gives Chubb an A++, Moody’s gives an Aa3 insurance financial strength rating, and S&P provides a credit rating of AA or A to the majority of Chubb’s subsidiaries. Chubb is a financially stable and strong business, so buyers should have no concerns about their financial strength.
In addition to exceptional financial strength, Chubb was rated “Better Than Most” in J.D. Power’s Issuer Satisfaction Study of Large Commercial Insurance Providers for the 3 major factors related to customer service – Overall Satisfaction, Service Interaction, and Claims. BBB ratings are unavailable for the main Chubb entity; however, many of the branches have A+ ratings. So Chubb stands among the leaders in customer satisfaction, particularly for larger companies, which is good if you are looking to insure a large construction business.
Chubb’s pricing for builders risk policies isn’t shared publicly because the price is so closely related to the details of each project. However, in the same J.D. Power study, Chubb was also rated “Better Than Most” in satisfaction of Pricing. This is a good sign if pricing is important to you or your company – existing customers are satisfied with the price and value of their insurance policies.
With Chubb as a top contender in all of our rating factors, they earned our recommendation as the Best Builders Risk Insurance Company for Commercial Developers.
Zurich Builders Risk (Best for New Home Construction; Best for Renovations, Remodels, & Additions)
Zurich is one of the longest standing insurers we reviewed and another one of our top recommendations for builders risk insurance coverage. They insure businesses of all sizes and are one of the most popular providers of builders risk insurance. In fact, Zurich is the second largest commercial property and casualty insurance provider in the United States.
If you are looking for a builders risk insurance policy in the United States through Zurich, Zurich instructs you to purchase through US Assure, who is “the program administrator and services provider” for the US region. This is because Zurich is an international company, based in Switzerland. However they provide top-notch coverage through US Assure. The policy offers many extensions which can remove most of the common exclusions for standard builders risk policies. US Assure also does a great job of explaining the Zurich policy and its options, making the coverage more transparent than most insurers.
Founded in 1872, Zurich is one of the oldest insurance companies in the world and the oldest provider of builders risk insurance. Financially, they have withstood the test of many market cycles, remaining in business for over 130 years. Zurich is one of the largest public companies in the world (SWX:ZURN). Beyond their strong track record, Zurich gets strong ratings from the top financial and insurance rating agencies, receiving financial strength ratings of A+, Aa3, and AA- from A.M. Best, Moody’s, and Standard & Poor’s respectively. Along with Zurich’s strong policy offering and financial strength comes a good reputation with their customers, which you can see in their A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
According to J.D. Power’s Large Company Insurer Study, Zurich’s pricing is about in line with the competition. However, Zurich does offer online quotes, through their subsidiary Zurich Financial Services’ website – InsuranceLinkDirect – which is useful for both businesses and homeowners. Getting a quote here will give you a good sense of what to expect, and could be a good benchmark to hold other insurers against.
Zurich is our pick for the Best Builders Risk Insurance Company for New Home Construction because they offer straightforward, yet flexible, builders risk insurance policies with enough flexibility for most new home construction projects. Through US Assure (Zurich’s US builders risk administrator), businesses and individuals can purchase policies specifically designed for new home construction. We also chose Zurich as the Best Builders Risk Insurance Company for Renovations, Remodels, and Additions because of their remodel-specific builders risk coverage.
Liberty Mutual Builders Risk (Best for Modular Homes)
Liberty Mutual released their builders risk coverage only within the last few years. However, they have been offering other forms of construction insurance for many more years, so they are experienced in the construction space. Beyond that, they were founded in 1912, so they have well over 100 years of experience providing other forms of insurance. This experience means they are trustworthy, even though this policy offering is new.
Liberty Mutual’s builders risk policy is extremely flexible because it offers a large number of optional coverage extensions. As far as insurance providers go, Liberty Mutual is one of the most transparent about their coverage options prior to receiving a quote. Their website clearly lays out their coverage options, so you know what the possibilities are without wasting time going through a potentially unnecessary quote process.
With regard to financial strength, Liberty Mutual is one of the stronger companies, with “Excellent” Financial Strength (A) and Long-Term Issuer Credit (a) ratings from A.M. Best. Moody’s gives Liberty Mutual an A2 Financial Strength Rating, which denotes superior financial strength when compared to the vast majority of other insurers. S&P Global also gives the company a financial strength rating of A, which is strong.
Like our other recommended providers, Liberty Mutual also has a strong reputation with its customers. The Better Business Bureau rating for the company is a B+, which leaves some room for improvement, but is still respectable. Similarly, J.D. Power’s Small Business Insurer Study (2018) rated Liberty Mutual as “Among the Best” of insurance providers in terms of positive customer interaction.
We pick Liberty Mutual as the Best Builders Risk Insurance Company for Modular Homes because they offer simple, yet flexible policies that you can easily extend to any number of simultaneous construction projects.